How to Increase Your VA Disability Rating: A Guide for Veterans

How to Increase Your VA Disability Rating: A Guide for Veterans

Latest News

Your VA disability rating directly shapes the monthly compensation you receive, the healthcare you can access, and the benefits available to your family. If your rating feels too low for what you live with every day, you are not alone, and you are not stuck. Veterans across Wisconsin and throughout the country successfully increase their ratings by understanding the process and building a stronger claim.

This guide walks through the most effective steps to pursue a higher rating.

What Does a VA Disability Rating Mean?

A VA disability rating is a percentage assigned by the VA that reflects the severity of a service-connected disability and its impact on average earning capacity.

The VA rates disabilities in increments of 10%, from 0% to 100%. A higher rating means higher monthly compensation under 38 U.S.C. § 1155, which authorizes the VA to set rating schedules based on average impairment of earning capacity. The VA uses the Combined Ratings Table to calculate a combined rating when a veteran has multiple disabilities, which often produces a result lower than the simple sum of individual ratings.

Understanding this math matters. Two separate 50% ratings do not combine to a 100% VA disability rating. Under the VA’s Combined Ratings Table, two 50% ratings combine to 75%, which is then rounded to 80%. Knowing how the VA combines ratings helps you identify gaps worth addressing.

Common Reasons a Rating May Be Too Low

Ratings are often too low because the original claim lacked sufficient medical evidence, conditions worsened, or secondary conditions were never claimed.

Several situations lead to underrated claims:

  • Medical records submitted at the time of the original claim did not fully document symptom severity
  • A condition has worsened since the last rating decision
  • New service-connected conditions developed after the original claim
  • Secondary conditions caused or aggravated by an already-rated disability were never filed
  • The VA applied an incorrect diagnostic code under the Schedule for Rating Disabilities (38 C.F.R. Part 4)

Each of these represents a potential path toward a higher rating.

Step 1: Request Your VA Records and Rating Decision

Before filing anything, review your VA medical records and, when appropriate, obtain a copy of your VA claims file. You can review and download VA medical records through the current My HealtheVet experience on VA.gov. A veteran can also request copies of VA medical records from the VA facility’s Release of Information office. The claims file, which contains records related to the VA’s adjudication of your benefits claim, may require a separate request. Review your rating decision letter closely. It will state which diagnostic code the VA used and why it assigned a specific percentage.

Identifying the exact diagnostic code is critical. The VA rates each condition according to specific criteria listed in 38 C.F.R. Part 4. If your symptoms meet the criteria for a higher rating under that code, you have a concrete basis to challenge the decision.

Step 2: Gather Updated Medical Evidence

Strong, current medical evidence is the foundation of any successful rating increase.

Schedule an appointment with your treating physician and ask for documentation that reflects your current level of impairment. The VA looks for objective findings, such as range-of-motion measurements for musculoskeletal conditions, psychiatric evaluation scores for mental health conditions, or pulmonary function test results for respiratory conditions.

A private medical opinion may strengthen your claim when medical expertise is needed to establish a connection between a condition and service or between a new condition and an already service-connected disability. For an increased-rating claim involving a disability that is already service-connected, the key issue is generally the current severity of the disability, so updated medical records, medical opinions, and competent lay evidence may be particularly important. Section 3.303 addresses principles of service connection, while secondary service connection is addressed under 38 C.F.R. § 3.310.

Step 3: File a Supplemental Claim or Request a Higher-Level Review

The Appeals Modernization Act (AMA) created three decision review options for veterans who disagree with a VA decision:

  • Supplemental Claim: Use this when you have new and relevant evidence that the VA did not previously consider. This can be an appropriate option when you have new medical evidence or other evidence supporting a higher rating.
  • Higher-Level Review Lane: A senior VA reviewer looks at the same evidence already in the file. No new evidence can be added, but this option may catch clear errors in the original decision.
  • Board Appeal: You can ask a Veterans Law Judge at the Board of Veterans’ Appeals to review your case. You can choose the Direct Review, Evidence Submission, or Hearing docket. The Direct Review docket does not allow new evidence or a hearing, while the Evidence Submission and Hearing dockets allow new evidence subject to the applicable rules.

Filing in the right lane depends on the specific facts of your situation. Choosing the wrong lane can delay your claim or limit your options.

Step 4: Consider Secondary Service Connection

Many veterans focus only on their primary diagnosed condition and overlook disabilities that developed as a direct result of that condition. The VA recognizes secondary service connection under 38 C.F.R. § 3.310, which allows compensation for a condition caused or chronically aggravated by an already service-connected disability.

For example, a veteran with a service-connected knee condition may seek secondary service connection for a back condition if competent evidence establishes the required connection. Similarly, a veteran with service-connected PTSD may seek secondary service connection for another condition if the evidence establishes that the condition was caused or aggravated by the PTSD. Secondary service connection is not automatic simply because two conditions occur together. Each secondary condition adds to the combined rating and, potentially, total compensation.

Step 5: Request a New C&P Examination If Warranted

If you claim that a service-connected condition has worsened, the VA may schedule a new Compensation and Pension (C&P) examination to evaluate its current severity. You should provide current medical evidence and accurately describe how the condition affects you in your daily life and work. Prepare for the exam by reviewing your symptoms thoroughly and being honest about how your condition affects your daily life, work, and relationships. During a C&P examination, be accurate and thorough when describing your symptoms and how they affect your daily life, work, and relationships. Do not minimize or exaggerate your symptoms. The information provided during the examination can be considered along with the other evidence in your claim.

Keep the Effective Date in Mind

When pursuing an increased rating, timing can matter. In some circumstances, VA can assign an effective date based on when it became factually ascertainable that the disability increased in severity, provided the claim is received within the applicable one-year period. Otherwise, the effective date is generally tied to when VA receives the claim. Veterans should consider these rules when deciding when to file for an increased rating.

When Legal Representation Makes a Difference

The claims process involves detailed regulations, strict deadlines, and medical evidence standards that are not always straightforward. Veterans working with an accredited VA attorney often see better outcomes because an attorney can identify rating errors, source strong medical opinions, and build a file the VA cannot easily overlook.

At West & Dunn, we represent Wisconsin veterans in VA disability claims and appeals. If your rating does not reflect what your service cost you, contact us or call us at 608-490-9449 to discuss your situation.

Related Articles