Is the Insanity Defense a “Get Out of Jail Free” Card? Understanding NGI Pleas in Wisconsin

Is the Insanity Defense a “Get Out of Jail Free” Card? Understanding NGI Pleas in Wisconsin

Criminal Defense
In this article, Associate Attorney Ty Gasparek explains how NGI pleas work in Wisconsin, addresses common misconceptions about the insanity defense, and outlines what defendants should understand about the process and its potential consequences.

Most people’s idea of the “insanity defense” comes from TV, movies, and what we see online. From that, some people get the idea that pleading insanity can function as a “get out of jail free card” or otherwise let someone who has been charged with a crime “get away” with it without facing consequences. In fact, the decision to plead not guilty by reason of mental disease or defect as it is called in Wisconsin (commonly referred to as NGI), should not be taken lightly and only after the client has a thorough understanding of what will happen and discussed options and strategy with an attorney familiar with the process.

An NGI plea is a claim that a defendant is not responsible for a crime because at the time, and due to mental disease or defect, they either did not have the capacity to appreciate the wrongfulness of their actions or the ability to conform their behavior to the law. It’s important to separate an NGI plea from a similar but distinct concept: a person’s competency to stand trial. A person is found incompetent when they are unable to understand the proceedings or unable to assist in their own defense. To simplify the difference, a person’s competency is related to their abilities and mental state while a case is ongoing, while NGI is concerned with a person’s mental state at the time the offense is alleged to have been committed.

How does someone plead NGI in Wisconsin?

Entering an NGI plea in Wisconsin is typically as simple as telling the Court that the defendant wishes to enter the plea on the record. Although it’s possible for this to happen at the same time as an initial plea of not guilty, it is more common for the NGI plea to come later in the proceedings after a defendant and their attorney have had a chance to review the strength of the State’s case and decide what their strategy will be to achieve the best outcome. In any event, the ultimate decision to enter an NGI plea is up to the client and not the attorney. This is another contrast with competency proceedings; attorneys have a duty to raise concerns related to competency to the court, even against their client’s wishes.

What happens after someone pleads NGI?

After an NGI plea is entered, the Court can appoint up to three (but typically just one) physicians or psychologists to meet with the defendant, review any relevant records, and write a report which is then submitted to the Court for the prosecution and defense to review. This report will include the examiner’s opinion regarding whether the defendant was able to appreciate the wrongfulness of their alleged actions or to conform their actions to the requirements of the law at the time of the alleged offense. In other words, the report contains the doctor’s opinion about whether the person meets the criteria for an NGI finding by answering the questions: did the person understand their actions were wrong, and were they able to control their actions at the time of the alleged crime?

The law also allows for a person to hire their own expert to perform the evaluation and write a report regarding their mental responsibility. This expert can then be called at a trial to testify and explain their findings to a jury. A defendant may want to do this when the report from the court-appointed doctor is not helpful to them, or they simply think another expert will be helpful in explaining the basis for the NGI plea to the jury. A defendant can even hire their own expert before formally entering their NGI plea. By doing this, the client and defense attorney can receive the report and review it with no initial obligation to turn it over to the prosecutor. This can be a crucial way to begin the NGI process in case of a concern that the report will contain information that will do more harm than good to the client’s case.

What happens during an NGI trial?

In Wisconsin, as in every state, most criminal cases do not proceed to trial but instead resolve through some sort of plea negotiations. NGI cases are not necessarily different in this regard, and the State and defense may simply agree to a finding of NGI without the need for a trial. However, trials do still occur, and the NGI plea adds another layer of complexity.

In a typical criminal jury trial, the State has the burden of proving beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant committed all elements of the charged crime or crimes, and all 12 jurors must agree on a finding of guilty or not guilty. NGI trials can begin with the same process. If a person wishes to maintain their initial “not guilty” plea alongside the NGI plea, the trial is split into two phases. In the first, the trial proceeds as normal, with the State having to prove that the defendant committed the crime. If the jurors decide the person is not guilty, then that is simply the end of the trial; the charges are dismissed, and the jurors never decide anything related to the NGI plea.

If, on the other hand, the jurors find the person guilty (or the defendant decides not to contest that portion and admits to the crime), the Court withholds an entry of judgment, and the trial moves on to the responsibility phase. This second phase is where the question of NGI comes into play. Here is where the experts who examined the defendant and wrote reports regarding the person’s mental state at the time of the crime are called to testify and explain their findings to a jury. This may look similar to the first phase of the trial, but there are two major differences: first, the defendant is the one who has the burden of proving the lack of mental responsibility due to NGI to “a reasonable certainty by the greater weight of the credible evidence,” and second, only five sixths of the jurors must agree to the verdict.

If the jurors find that the defendant hasn’t proved their claim of NGI, then the judge enters a judgment of conviction, and the person is sentenced the same as anyone else who is convicted of a crime. If the jurors agree that the defendant was NGI, then the defendant is not convicted criminally, and instead the Court enters a judgment of not guilty by reason of mental disease or defect, and the proceedings move on to the commitment as opposed to sentencing.

What happens after someone is found NGI?

An NGI commitment occurs after the Court has entered a judgment of not guilty by reason of mental disease or defect, whether that occurs after a successful jury trial defense or by simply entering the plea if the State and defense agree to the NGI finding. The Court then has to decide, after hearing argument from the defense, the State, and potentially ordering a report from the Department of Health Services, how long the commitment should last and whether the commitment will begin with what is called “institutional care” (inpatient treatment in a mental health facility the person is not allowed to leave) or “conditional release” (outpatient treatment in the community under supervision).

The length of the commitment will depend on what crimes the person was charged with and ultimately found NGI. For felonies, the commitment can be up to the same length of time that the defendant could be ordered to an initial period of confinement in prison had they been criminally convicted. For misdemeanors, the commitment can be up to two-thirds of the maximum term of imprisonment had they been criminally convicted. Where the person will begin their commitment is determined by the judge. The law instructs judges to order institutional care if the Court finds by clear and convincing evidence that releasing the person to the community would pose a significant risk of bodily harm to themselves or others, or of serious property damage. If the evidence doesn’t show that level of risk, the judge must release the person to conditional release.

It’s important to note that this is just the initial place of treatment. A person who is ordered to institutional care has the right to petition the Court for conditional release, and a person who is released can be sent to institutional care if they are later found to pose a danger to themselves or others, or serious property damage. Therefore, people who are ordered to inpatient treatment will want to cooperate with treatment and show progress to hopefully be released, and those who are allowed to do treatment in the community will want to cooperate and follow their rules of supervision to allow them to stay in the community.

Conclusion

Entering an NGI plea is a serious decision that should not be taken lightly. Even if a defendant is successful and found NGI, there may still be serious consequences including a prohibition against owning firearms, placement on the sex offender registry, and extensive confinement for treatment. It’s important to keep in mind that this article is an overview of the process, and no article could cover every situation with these complex cases.

For a thorough assessment of your case, speak with an attorney experienced in Wisconsin’s NGI process. The criminal defense attorneys at West & Dunn can help you understand your options and guide you through the legal process. To discuss your situation and next steps, reach out through our Contact Us page or call (608) 535-6420.

Related Articles